When success in the video game industry is often measured in increments of millions, it should come as no surprise that most high profile games are under a huge amount of scrutiny from the day that a gameplay trailer is shown to the day that the developers cease to support their product. This is especially true when a developer or publisher claims that their game is the most successful new gaming franchise of all time or states that they have over 25 million registered users; yes, there are a lot of people playing your game, but that means that there are that many more pairs of eyes capable of tearing apart every mechanic or feature. Of all the games that have undergone such a trial, though, one in particular stands out: Destiny.
Of course, many people were (cautiously) optimistic about a game that was created by the developers of Halo and backed by Activision. At first, this seemed to be the case, with millions buying the game on release, their purchase seemingly justified given how positive the initial reactions were. Word of mouth, impressive reviews, and overwhelming amounts of coverage made it seem like Destiny was going to be the game that defined the decade. However, rumors of discontent started popping up, seeding doubt in people's minds. Day by day, people started to ask things like "Why am I getting loot that is of a lower quality than the box that it came in?", "Why am I only getting the same cosmetic item from the Vault of Glass over and over again?", and "What do you mean I'm not playing the game as Bungie intended?"
Things only got worse as Destiny's DLC packs came out. Statements like "You're telling me that I don't have enough friends to play my game?", "Where's the story?", and "Time to go onto a website to find people to play with" became more and more common. Naturally, people started leaving the game as frustration over things like the pure randomness of loot, the questionable balancing of weapons, and the horribly time consuming nature of the end game content reached its apex. Things got a little better with The Taken King DLC (with no shortage of people claiming that it revolutionized the game), but it proved to be more of the same: lots of grinding, no in-game matchmaking for end game content, and fairly disappointing loot mechanics. Within a month or so of The Taken King's release, it certainly felt like Bungie ignored some of the more common criticisms of Destiny simply because it was a way to artificially inflate their playtime stats. To add insult to injury, the DLC gradually became mandatory as more and more activities became tied to the purchase of the DLC.
To their credit, Bungie gave Destiny amazing core gameplay mechanics (after all, no one ever complained about your character being clumsy or awkward to control), but they failed at making Destiny a game that had any longevity to it, or at least the longevity that Bungie hoped for. Realistically speaking, most people could beat the campaign within a few hours and with very little difficulty (or for that matter any comprehension of the story), which usually put them in a position to play the end-game content. Unfortunately, said end-game content turned out to be either repetitive, restrictive in that you need to have at least two other friends online to attempt it, or simply nonexistent. On top of that, the only reliable way to obtain good loot was through playing the same Raid over and over and over again, only for the inevitable release of the next DLC to render your efforts moot.
Similarly, The Crucible (the competitive multiplayer portion of Destiny) was initially regarded very favorably, but when it was discovered that it was in no way shape or form balanced so that every weapon was viable, it quickly became a contest to see who had the best shotgun (or Thorn). Plus, like the rest of Destiny, the rewards that you could get from the conclusion of a Crucible match were not influenced by how well you performed. Eventually, Bungie fixed these issues, but it took them many months to do so. Needless to say, Destiny quickly gained a reputation as being the game that was incredibly fun to play, but only if you judged the game based on first impressions or the fact that most of the game's enjoyment came from playing with your friends. With Destiny's Rise of Iron DLC coming out soon, it would be wise to remember that although Destiny excels in certain aspects, it created a legacy where people unquestionably became even more wary of developers and their promises.