Three French activist organizations stated that they plan to file legal complaints against popular social media sites that they believe are in violation of the country’s hate speech laws. They claim to have found numerous examples of hate speech, but only a small fraction was taken down by the social media platforms.
The French Jewish Students Union (UEJF), SOS Racisme and SOS Homophobie are targeting Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube with their complaints. They claim to have documented 586 examples of “hate speech” between the end of March and May 10. They report that Twitter deleted four percent of the hateful content, Youtube deleted seven percent and Facebook deleted 34 percent. The organizations believe these companies are in clear violation of French law which requires sites to remove content that is racist, homophobic or antisemitic, and to report the content to authorities.
A joint press release was published by the organizations. UEJF president Sacha Reingewirtz called on the social media giants to do more to combat hate speech and stated, “In light of Youtube, Twitter and Facebook’s profits and how little taxes they pay, their refusal to invest in the fight against hate is unacceptable.”
This is not the first time social media companies have been targeted under European hate speech laws. In December, Facebook, Twitter and Google all made a pledge to delete hate speech within 24 hours, as a result of pressure from the German government. Earlier this year, Facebook took even stronger measures to deal with xenophobic content that was posted on its platform after German prosecutors began investigating the company. In addition to pledging over a million dollars to combat online extremism, Facebook also hired the services of a German media company to monitor the site and delete hate speech.
Should Facebook, Twitter and YouTube do more to police hate speech that is posted on their platforms? Do hate speech laws interfere with free speech? How should international media and social media companies deal with the huge variety of laws in the world? Leave your comments below!